Buyer’s Guide: Cooling Mattress Toppers

**This post contains affiliate links and I will be compensated if you make a purchase after clicking on my links

If you are a fan of purchasing mattresses online, you know most come in one firmness. On a scale of 1-10, with 10 being the firmest, most mattresses target around 5-7. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, as 80% of sleepersOpens in a new tab. are happy with “medium” or “medium-firm”.

Your preferred sleep position will affect your preferred firmness. Back and stomach sleepers are fine with firmer mattresses, however, side sleepers may find they need additional cushioning on pressure points, like hips and shoulders.

If this is the case, you can add a little padding. If you need just smidge, consider a quilted mattress pad.

If you need more, check out a mattress topper, which adds from 1-4 inches of extra cushiness. Choose the thickness based on how much cushiness you wish to add.

Topper + mattress pad

Place your protective mattress pad over both the topper and mattress. Ideally, your mattress pad has a layer of breathable waterproof polyurethane, which will protect both topper and mattress from any fluid spills.

Most toppers have corner straps to keep it in place. If you’re combining a topper with a mattress pad, the stretchy sides of the pad will help keep everything in place on top of your mattress.

Finding the perfect topper may take a bit of trial and error, especially when the temperature is part of the comfort equation. Before making a purchase, always check for a generous return policy.

These days, the minimum standard is 30-days, in line with the return policy of your favorite online store. The more time you have to try out your topper, the better.

Toppers generally come in two types: quilted or solid foam.

Quilted toppers

Quilted toppers have a quilted cover and are stuffed with the same type of materials you find in comforters: polyester, down, or wool. Sometimes shredded memory foam. Unlike a comforter, these fills are significantly denser, as they need to hold your weight.

Assuming a quilted topper fits in your washing machine, it may or may not be machine washable.

  • Sleep & Beyond myTopperOpens in a new tab.. Filled with 100% washable (cruelty-free) Shropshire wool. (Also available in non-washable merino wool.) 100% organic cotton cover. 1.5” thick.

Wool in this topper is described as down-like. Wool is a breathable fiber that absorbs moisture, keeping you dry. This is important in all seasons: you stay warm in winter, and cool in summer.

[Standard 30-day return policy from your favorite online store]

  • Therapedic® Polar Nights™ 10X Cooling Ice Cube Mattress TopperOpens in a new tab.. Gel-infused memory foam cubes (20%) plus polyester gel fiberfill (80%). REACTEX Cooling Technology, stores and releases heat as needed. Pressure-activated cooling in 8 seconds. 2” thick. Spot clean only.
    • According to the online reviews, it’s unclear whether this topper stays cool after the initial “pressure”. You may need to readjust your position to stay cool.

      [240-day return policy.]

    Foam toppers

    Foam toppers are usually a single piece of solid foam but can also be made of layers of different foam.

    Premium foam toppers use memory foam. This foam is great at cradling your weight, however, there are a few downsides.

    One, it’s slow to respond. If you change positions or try to get up, you may find yourself slightly “stuck”.

    Two, is heat transfer. First-generation memory foam was notoriously hot. Newer memory foam has an open-cell structure to encourage air circulation. In addition, the foam may be infused with cooling agents, such as gel, copper, or graphite. Are these cooling agents enough to compensate for the memory foam and keep you cool?

    Memory foam and similar toppers may arrive vacuum sealed. They may need to “off-gas” for a day or so, and also may need that time to fully inflate. Take a few nights, or even a week, to decide whether your topper will work for you.

    >> Check out my full review of the Bear ProTopper HEREOpens in a new tab..

     

    • Bear ProTopperOpens in a new tab.. Copper-infused memory foam with Celliant® technology. 2” thick.

    Copper is antimicrobial, inhibiting the growth of bacteria and other things. In addition, it also has cooling properties.

    CelliantOpens in a new tab. captures body heat and transforms it into infrared (IR) energy. As an added benefit, this IR energy improves oxygen delivery to the skin. Celliant has been classified by the FDA as a medical device.

    [100-night sleep trial]

    Other Cooling foam toppers

    • Layla Memory Foam TopperOpens in a new tab.. Copper-infused memory foam, with a thermo-gel cooling cover, that activates with body temperature. 2” thick.

    [120-night money-back guarantee]

    [45-day return policy]

    Opens in a new tab.Resources & Reviews

    Mattress Additions

    Review:
    Nectar mattress

    Covers for mattresses & pillows

    Mattress toppers—Cooling

    Review:
    Bear ProTopper

    Bedding—Cooling

    Mattress pads

    Review:
    Bear Mattress Protector

    Sheets

    Blankets & Comforters

    Pillows

    Review:
    Mediflow water pillow

    Bedding—Cozy

    Weighted blankets

    Review:
    Bearaby Tree Napper

    Heated Blankets & Mattress pads

    Wool Blankets & Comforters

    Bedroom climate

    Air filtration

    Humidifiers

    Bed heating & cooling systems

    Review:
    BeJet 3.0

    Extras

    Sleep aids

    Review:
    Sleep Headphones

    Smart Bedroom